More filters. Sort order. Aug 13, Michael Burnam-Fink rated it it was amazing Shelves: , war. I'll freely confess to being an armchair warrior, but this is one of the best books I've read on counter-insurgency: clear, detailed, exciting in parts, and with no jargon. Tinquier has unassailable experience, as the commander of a 20, strong Montagnard army in French Indochina, and then later some of the most effective French airborne forces in Algeria. True, France lost both those wars, but defeats are profound learning experiences. Trinquier explains how insurgencies develop from a small p I'll freely confess to being an armchair warrior, but this is one of the best books I've read on counter-insurgency: clear, detailed, exciting in parts, and with no jargon.
Trinquier explains how insurgencies develop from a small political-military core into mass movements capable of bringing down governments, how they aim to outlast their conventional foes, and how they can be defeated. He argues that the guerrillas are the most expendable part of the organization, and that defeating them is irrelevant.
The logistical core of the movement is the true target, and finding it requires building a complete civilian intelligence service, that links everybody to their house and social position household, hamlet, village, district, etc , and then to a system that gathers human intelligence and funnels it to the military police. As a first step, Trinquier suggests locating and arresting the rebel tax collectors, since they must have contact with the population and are inevitably unpopular.
Then, the enemy network can be tracked, located, and rolled up. His attitude is brutally realistic. Fans of a 'clean wars' will be disturbed by his advocacy of torture "The terrorist expects to be tortured in the same way the infantryman expects to be machine-gunned, or the aviator shot at by flak. On the other hand, he also puts protection of the population at the center of the strategy, and makes legitimate government a cornerstone of a successful campaign.
Absolutely vital for anybody interested in guerrilla warfare View 1 comment. Jan 12, Azriel rated it really liked it. A shockingly clearheaded, accessible, and terse statement of counterinsurgency principles, levened by an unusual compassion toward the populace and the insurgent fighters.
Nov 28, Roger Burk rated it liked it. This book has modest fame as one of the first on how to fight an insurgency. It is clearly written with a readily understood program, and it is quite wrongheaded.
It makes absolutely no mention of the fact that insurgencies are sustained by legitimate grievances in the population, that as other writers have said insurgencies are primarily a political problem, not a military one. It should be noted that the author had extensive experience in fighting insurgencies, in Indochina and in Algeria--in This book has modest fame as one of the first on how to fight an insurgency. It should be noted that the author had extensive experience in fighting insurgencies, in Indochina and in Algeria--in both of which the insurgents won, despite some tactical and even operational victories by the French.
In Trinquier's program, the army moves into a city suffering an insurgency and makes a strict census, issues identity cards, establishes a curfew, establishes a hierarchy of civilian leaders down to the block level, and interrogates all of them privately.
In a few months this will give the army a good idea of who the lowest-level insurgent agents are. Then in one night, the army descends on these enemies, gets information on their higher-ups by any means necessary, and rounds them up the same night. Any dissent from this program is treated as treason. This is no lieutenant's war--it is thoroughly planned at the theater level. In this way, the insurgency is wiped out in short order, you see.
In that city, at that moment. It should be noted that this worked in Algiers, though a little later the French lost Algeria. We are not to worry about the implications for freedom of the extensive and pervasive network of informers--it is only necessary during the actual insurgency--but it also needs to be created ahead of the insurgency, so that things never get out of hand--Tranquier never squares that circle.
In one place the insurgents are said to readily give information because they have been coerced into service, and in another they are said to be ideologically committed. No explanation there either.
Modern Warfare: A French View of Counterinsurgency
Torture to quickly get military information from captives and for no other purpose, it should be noted is a moral necessity. There is no guidance on how to tell true from false information, or how to avoid having citizens use false denunciations to settle private scores. In the countryside, things are a little different.
The usual outposts, patrols, ambushes, sweeps, and so forth are all useless. The rural areas are to be cleared of insurgents and left "absolutely uninhabitable" p. Sep 29, Alan rated it liked it. The best book to describe the "ends justify the means" school of Counterinsurgency thought.
Jul 08, Gonzalo rated it it was amazing.
You are here
A seminal work on the theory and practice of counter-insurgency. Well-thought, practical, comprehensive; also politically incorrect, brutal and ridden with illegal advice. Nevertheless, a must-read. Apr 06, Michael rated it really liked it. Anyone interested in counterinsurgency must read it.
- Modern Warfare: A French View of Counterinsurgency - Roger Trinquier - Google книги;
- Account Options!
- The Lyncher In Me.
- Bestselling Series!
- Matrix partial orders, shorted operators and applications.
- Microwave Transistor Amplifiers: Analysis and Design!
His basic premise is simple enough. His solutions of how to recognize the enemy, organize friendly forces and territory, and methods to defeat the adversary are all worth reading and can be seen to have influenced counter-insurgency ever since including U. BUT and you were waiting for this I can tell he makes several false assumptions and ultimately is discussing modern warfare at the tactical-operational level and not the strategic. For some reason, obtaining information by torture from soldiers and partisans is not useful.
He never explains why but there is no inherently logical reason that obtaining information from a terrorist is useful but not the other two types of combatants. The adversary would clearly like to know from captured soldiers and partisans of plans, capabilities, etc.
Why not use torture there? Why does he distinguish it for terrorists only? He has other problems when it comes to torture, such as assuming that the skilled interrogators will find that one precise piece of information they want and halt the torture. Has that been the historical case?
This critique is a detail, however. His fundamental problem is that the modern warfare he has experienced is not an internal problem within a European nation subverted by alien ideas or forces but in areas where the Europeans are occupiers. Yes, his example of Algeria, for him, fits the bill. Boeken van Eliot A.
Modern Warfare: A French View of Counterinsurgency - Roger Trinquier - Google книги
Filter 20 resultaten. Cohen The Big Stick Ebook. Direct beschikbaar. Verkoop door bol. Ebook Op verlanglijstje. Soldiers, Statesmen, and Leadership in Wartime. Vanaf 18 -. Toon tweedehands.
Cohen The Big Stick. Direct beschikbaar Levertijd We doen er alles aan om dit artikel op tijd te bezorgen. Luister met Kobo Plus. Luisterboek Op verlanglijstje. Eliot A Cohen Eliot A. Cohen Supreme Command. In winkelwagen Op verlanglijstje. Andrew J Bacevich Eliot A. Cohen War Over Kosovo. Verwacht over 6 weken Levertijd We doen er alles aan om dit artikel op tijd te bezorgen. Roger Trinquier Modern Warfare. Vanaf 7 -. Vanaf 13 Cohen Cohen, James Supreme Command. Thomas A.
Keaney Eliot A. WordPress Shortcode. Published in: Education. Full Name Comment goes here. Are you sure you want to Yes No. Be the first to like this. No Downloads. Views Total views.
- The science of laboratory diagnosis!
- See a Problem?;
- Create a New Idea List;
- Search form!
- Practical Policing Skills for Student Officers, 2nd Edition;
- A Companion to Asian Art and Architecture.
Actions Shares. Embeds 0 No embeds. No notes for slide. If you want to download this book, click link in the next page 5.